The Property Perspective is a weekly radio show on 919 FM, airing every Tuesday at 4:15 PM with Al and Lesedi on The Drive Train.
Episode 29 | The Property Perspective with Etchells & Young
Your lease is coming to an end and your landlord has proposed a rental increase. Do you have to accept it, can you negotiate, or would moving be a better option?
In Episode 29, Harry explains how to assess a proposed rental increase, approach lease renewals and work out the real cost of staying versus moving.
In This Episode
Harry looks at the questions tenants should ask before agreeing to a new rental or deciding to move.
Harry discusses:
Whether a tenant must accept a proposed rental increase
What the lease and renewal notice actually say
How to assess whether a rent increase is market-related
Negotiating a renewal with your landlord
The benefits of a good landlord-tenant relationship
Comparing the costs of renewing with the costs of moving
Why you should act before your lease expires
Getting agreed renewal terms confirmed in writing
Listen to Episode 29
Do you have to accept a rental increase?
A proposed increase when your lease comes up for renewal is not necessarily a figure you have to accept without discussion. Harry explains that there may be room for negotiation, depending on the agreement and the landlord’s willingness to renew.
Start with your existing lease. Look for any escalation provisions, renewal options and notice requirements. Understanding what you have already agreed to is the first step before responding to a new rental proposal.
When should you receive a renewal notice?
Harry explains that, where section 14 of the Consumer Protection Act applies, a tenant should receive notice of the approaching expiry of a fixed-term lease between 40 and 80 business days before it ends.
The notice should explain the options available and any proposed material changes, including the new rental. Not every residential lease is subject to the same provisions, so tenants should also check the terms of their own agreement.
At Etchells & Young, the rental portfolio team monitors upcoming expiries and communicates with tenants and landlords ahead of renewal.
Is the proposed increase market-related?
There is no single annual rental increase percentage prescribed for every residential property. Harry recommends looking at the rental market in the relevant suburb, complex or estate.
Compare your property with similar homes currently advertised for rent. If comparable properties are available for less, that information may help you negotiate. If your rent has remained below market levels for several years, some adjustment may be reasonable.
How to negotiate with your landlord
If you look after the property, pay your rent on time and have a constructive relationship with your landlord, explain why you would like to stay and what increase you can afford.
Harry recommends putting a professional proposal in writing, supported by examples of comparable rentals. A landlord may also weigh up the cost of losing a reliable tenant and having the property vacant while a replacement is found.
Once you reach an agreement, make sure the new rental and other renewal terms are recorded in writing.
Should you renew your lease or move?
A less expensive monthly rental does not automatically make moving the better financial decision. Removal costs, a new deposit, possible overlap between two rental payments and other upfront expenses all need to be considered.
Think about the effect of a different location on your commute, school runs and daily routine. Harry suggests comparing the total costs over a year, rather than looking at the new monthly rental on its own.
What to do before your lease expires
Take out your signed lease and confirm the expiry date, the renewal provisions and any deadlines you need to meet. Read the landlord’s or managing agent’s notice carefully and ask questions about anything that is unclear.
If you want to negotiate, do so early. If you agree to renew, finalise and sign the renewal documentation before the current term ends, rather than leaving the decision until the last minute.
Three things tenants should remember
First, read your renewal notice and diarise important dates. Second, support any negotiation with facts about comparable rentals in your area. Third, if you are considering moving, compare the full financial and lifestyle costs before deciding.
The main message from Harry is to treat a renewal notice as the start of a process. Know your options, communicate clearly and make sure the outcome is agreed in writing.
Property of the Week
Phil Steinberg shares a renovated three-bedroom, two-bathroom townhouse in Boskruin, Randburg. The property features a tandem garage, a storage area, 24-hour security, a swimming pool and pet-friendly facilities in the complex.
The asking price quoted during the episode is R1,450,000. Check the current price and availability with Etchells & Young before enquiring.
What is The Property Perspective?
The Property Perspective is Etchells & Young's weekly property segment on 919 FM.
Each episode explores a different aspect of property - from rentals and property management to buying, selling, legislation, sectional title living and the everyday questions property owners and tenants face.
Follow the series as we unpack more of the issues that matter to Johannesburg property owners, buyers, sellers, landlords and tenants.
Need help with your lease renewal?
Whether you are reviewing a proposed rental increase, deciding whether to move or managing a residential investment, speak to the Etchells & Young team for practical guidance on rentals and lease renewals.